Ask Lemmy
A Fediverse community for open-ended, thought provoking questions
Rules: (interactive)
1) Be nice and; have fun
Doxxing, trolling, sealioning, racism, and toxicity are not welcomed in AskLemmy. Remember what your mother said: if you can't say something nice, don't say anything at all. In addition, the site-wide Lemmy.world terms of service also apply here. Please familiarize yourself with them
2) All posts must end with a '?'
This is sort of like Jeopardy. Please phrase all post titles in the form of a proper question ending with ?
3) No spam
Please do not flood the community with nonsense. Actual suspected spammers will be banned on site. No astroturfing.
4) NSFW is okay, within reason
Just remember to tag posts with either a content warning or a [NSFW] tag. Overtly sexual posts are not allowed, please direct them to either [email protected] or [email protected].
NSFW comments should be restricted to posts tagged [NSFW].
5) This is not a support community.
It is not a place for 'how do I?', type questions.
If you have any questions regarding the site itself or would like to report a community, please direct them to Lemmy.world Support or email [email protected]. For other questions check our partnered communities list, or use the search function.
6) No US Politics.
Please don't post about current US Politics. If you need to do this, try [email protected] or [email protected]
Reminder: The terms of service apply here too.
Partnered Communities:
Logo design credit goes to: tubbadu
Turning living things into food is technically what most animals do every day just to live.
All living things are already food
Including humans!
Super speed. So... Let's say you can move at light speed, and let's just hand-wave away the problems like turning everything in front of you into an exploding ball of superhot plasma or shattering the Earth's crust with every step. We'll just take as a given that you can actually use this power.
Would you want to?
Let's be clear... This isn't teleportation, this is being able to move at super speed. That means you still experience all the motion between point A and point B. That could go one of two ways:
- Your mind can also operate at super speed. Great! You're running across the United States? You get to experience every single footstep. You get to experience the subjective time it takes to walk or run ~3000 miles - five to seven months. Depending on how much control over your subjective experience of time you have, maybe you can make it feel like you're going at the speed of a car on a highway or something, but you're still looking at a week or so of subjective time. Hope you like time alone, because you're going to have millions of years of it, from your perspective, if you use your power a lot. But that's still better than the alternative...
- Your mind operates at normal speed. You are now the most dangerous thing on the planet. Every time you use your super speed, the landscape blurs around you and you have no idea where you are, how far you've gone, or how many people you've exploded into red mists without even realizing they're there along the way. You could easily plow through a line of buses filled with orphans and puppies, and never even notice the trail of carnage behind you, because they were in New Jersey, and you stopped in San Diego.
That's why the comics always gloss over what it's like to have super speed. The dark side of it is that for it to be anything but terrifyingly destructive to the entire planet, you have to have control. And in order for you to have control, you have to be capable of seeing where you're going and reacting to obstacles. That means sped up perceptions, and thus the subjective hell of experiencing every single step you take at super speed.
I would guess that you have seen the first episode of "The Boys"?
Anyway, option 1 is very clearly superior, even if incredibly boring, because it includes not becoming tired or hungry during the trip. You kinda would get to zone out for months at a time, like a super long scenic vacation.
Option 1 also isn't necessarily as bad as they make it seem. If you suddenly gained super speed and your perception of time altered over night then, yes, you're suddenly going be spending a lot more time in your own head relative to before and it's going to take some adjustment as best, a lot of therapy at worst. But if you're born like that, surely it'd just be normal for you and you wouldn't necessarily know anything different?
The other option that wasn't mentioned is that you can "turn on" your powers and the world feels like it goes into slow motion around you, and then you turn them off again afterwards and it's all back to normal.
I've seen an explanation somewhere that I likes which is super speed and super reflexes are like tensing two different muscles.
You can make your body move at 10x speed to run across town (even 2-3 speed makes you faster than the fastest humans and 5* is like a car going quickly), then you use your reflexes 3 times faster to make that superspeed feel like only 3 times your natural speed. You can also seperate them in other ways like buying yourself time in an exam by speeding up your thinking without actually increasing your muscle movement.
Your mental and physical speed being like tensing muscles also means you can have them kick in like a withdrawal reflex. As the air pressure changes before an explosion or bullet hits you, you involuntarily crank your limit to 50x speed (or whatever is required) to dodge.
It also has the obvious weakness of being exhaustable. It's worth mentioning that 10x speed is absolutely enough to do most superhuman abilities, and 3x speed makes you basically better than most humans, not just at running but also dodging and punching, and it's absolutely up to the storyteller to decide if such a low speed multiplier exhausts said speedster or if they can maintain that indefinitely like the muscles we use to stand.
Don’t Invincible and the Boys have a speedster for both those two outcomes?
barry Allen the flash aswell i think.
Also even if you are protected from the repercussions of moving at super speed, anything you move isn’t. If you carry your friend across the street, your friend is now pulverized and probably burnt to a crisp. If you move your water bottle, congrats on delivering a pressure vessel of steam to wherever you just went. Acceleration that fast and impacts at that speed would destroy basically everything you touch while moving at super speed.
If you have the power of super speed you can control when it’s active. Likewise you can adjust the speed your mind processes things to always ensure you’re 1:1 with your frame of reference.
Being 1:1 with your frame of reference is actually one of the problems.
Say you're Barry Allen and you're running from Los Angeles to New York city. Given the nature of your powers, you arrive there basically instantly as far as anyone else is concerned.
But for you? You experience every single footstep you took along the way. You arrive bored out of your mind and possibly going insane after running across the continental United States in, for you, months of being absolutely alone in a world of utterly still statues and an unmoving sun.
That’s why I said you can adjust it. But if you did it in a flash you wouldn’t be able to avoid obstacles in time and you’d be a fine red mist.
A lot of people have read this question to mean the accurate scientific implications of everyday superpowers which isn't really in the spirit of superpowers. I'll try to say powers that feel generally altruistic or built for cute characters that have cruel implications.
Healing us the classic cute superpower, but if the user of the power chooses to overheal somebody they could probably cause basically mega cancer.
It's pretty easy to imagine the the implications of controlling animals, and it's a pretty good power to sit in the background as a utility power until the user decides to have every insect, rat and pigeon in the city bombard somebody.
The ability to share memories is hard to be used villainously but two fucked applications would be to beam somebody's traumatic experience I to somebody else's head (or an experience that happened to one person that could trigger someone else's PTSD), or if the user has trained themselves to be able to alter their memories to fictional events on demand, turning what is basically a truth finding superpower into an abuse of perceived honesty.
Finally the superpower of using Reddit and Lemmy your whole life and generating a very standard way if responding but having the cruel and unusual twist of always sounding like fucking ChatGPT.
The power of healing could be used to infinitely torture someone without killing them. Definitely has a dark side.
All power must be applied ethically
The heal to cancer ratio is a perfect example, deepens the power itself too instead of being a superficial “you’re fixed now!” vibe
Your example reminded me of this classic: Jesus: Water into Wine
Jesus Christ
Cheese and Rice!
It's Jason Bourne
Avatar covered water bending including blood. My hero academia does a really good job with covering pretty big disadvantages to powers.
Blood bending sure is a creepy one.
Here is an entire novel (free online) written by a master at 'what else could a given superpower do or cause?'
It's an amazing read if you like the genre at all.
Just a warning, it gets very grimdark in a lot of places.
Knew what it was before I clicked. Definitely second the recommendation, have read multiple times, and I'm almost through the sequel.
X-ray vision is horrible for cancer rates (though one could argue that, since it doesn't work like normal x-ray in many comics, that it's some other magic with the name x-ray for convenience).
Well, I always figured that “x ray vision” was just eyes that were super sensitive to the natural background radiation everywhere, and not that they were actually transmitting x rays
I'm also not sure if transmitting x-rays would work
It's not like radar, you'd need to also be on the other side to collect the data after it passed through the object
That depends on whether the x-rays are absorbed by the bone/solid material or reflected.
I don’t know enough about x-rays to answer that.
As a counterpoint, combining Cyclops's power with x-ray vision is a fun power combination, and it's an interesting take to imagine his power as just cooking everything with radiation.
I mean that’s kinda what lasers do….. but also interesting
Pretty sure xray vision can just see the xray band of the electromagnetic spectrum
I think superman can probably see the entire or a larger range than humans and can consciously filter it
They touched on that a little bit in Superman Redson, Lex tried to make a Superman clone and its x-ray vision did all the horrible things of an actual x-ray. It was a super short bit, but I found it neat.
The ability to time travel, allows you to change anything except yourself.
Dark taught me that time travel will change something, but you won't know because the time machine and it's idea will be destroyed in its process.
Technically you could if you made precise calculations to change your personal timeline
I think that line of reasoning will quickly become a ouroboros situation when you think about the details of cause, effect and desire.
I suppose the best outcome is the one where you've destroyed yourself and are replaced with a nearly identical person sans the reason you changed time and the butterfly effect of everything that stemmed from that.
At worst you've duplicated yourself and have a wonderful opportunity to observe yourself blissfully unaware of the reason you changed time.
But depending on which flavor of time travel used. I suspect the most likely outcome is you'll continue doing this again and again. Something always misaligning with your goals potentially unaware that anything has already happened. Never seemingly perfect or that time becomes this window of experience looping, endless eight style.
You don't need superpowers to turn humans into food...
Telepathy. You would get their mental illnesses too. Imagine telepathic combatants on a battlefield and suddenly everyone has PTSD because one guy stepped in a trap.
Check out the graphic novel series called Chew the characters all have obscure food super powers
Power corrupts people.
There's no reason to assume that this could be different with super powers.