this post was submitted on 14 Sep 2023
1527 points (95.7% liked)
Memes
45886 readers
1656 users here now
Rules:
- Be civil and nice.
- Try not to excessively repost, as a rule of thumb, wait at least 2 months to do it if you have to.
founded 5 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
I wanted to do a "to be fair here, Cash had songs with stupid lyrics, too", but all I can think of is "Ring of fire" and that one is just a harmless metaphor about love.
I'd argue that Ring of Fire is a metaphor about forbidden love that you know is damning you but the feelings are too powerful to resist.
Rather than a harmless metaphor, I find it an incredibly powerful metaphor about the pain and suffering caused by helplessly loving the "wrong" person.
Plus, there's an opportunity to make STD jokes.
It'd be a more powerful metaphor if he wasn't a massive manwhore and his "love" wasn't any fan with great tits, or his second wife's sister.
Well, yeah. No one said he wasn't flawed.
Yeah, that was the point, you nailed it fam.
He didn't actually write Ring of Fire
He didn't write several of his songs. That's really common. Many writers are not performers.
Ring of Fire was written by June Carter, and first released by her sister Anita Carter.
"One Piece at a Time" is less of a country song and more of a novelty song.
Yes, so is "hey porter" or "boy named sue", but those are sung jokes of a sort which gives them a purpose ;)
And A Boy Named Sue was written by Shel Silverstein, so you can't really pick on that one.
You absolutly can pick on it and you should, and you'd wholeheartedly agree if you knew the sequal song Shell wrote.
I'm intrigued. Educate me.
Here's audio
And here's the lyrics
Basically tells the story from the dads perspective.
Tldr the dad fucks the boy.
Damn. :(
Ring of fire is my song to sing when I've had too much Mexican food and beer.
I don't think modern country even uses metaphors anymore. Before anyone comes at me, I'm well awair that there's some fantactic country writers out there.
That's because modern country is squarely focused on (far) right leaning people and they are utterly deaf, dumb and blind to any sort of metaphor, sarcasm and subtlety.
It's why these pricks go nuts for songs like Killing in the Name, not realizing it's a song that explicitly hates on them saying stuff like "some of those who work forces, are the same that BURN CROSSES".
They only see and hear that title and have no fucking clue what it and the rest of the song is actually about.
Also see: "Born in the USA".
Way back when Nirvana, Tool, RATM and all the great early 90's bands were coming up, there was another.
A dingy Swedish band named Clawfinger.
They had a debut, self released album named Deaf Dumb Blind and it's most well known song was named Nigger.
The song sprung outrage with the conservative right in the US, because back then they pretended they were against racism and the use of that word.
Clawfinger was similar in lyrical meaning with Rage Against the Machine, most of their songs were protest songs.
These are the lyrics.
(guess I'll link it as I can't find how to do spoiler tags ...)
Rember when Cobain wrote "rape me" becuase he had to hit people in the head with the message because the song "polly" went right over it?
It's always wise to satisfy the requests of time squirrels. Keeps them away from one's nuts.
"One piece at a time"
Also still fairly anti capitalism. The whole core is "I worked at a Cadillac factory making cars I could never afford with what they paid".
That's a classic, and I won't hear one word against it.
And it didn't cost me a dime!