this post was submitted on 02 Feb 2024
518 points (99.1% liked)
Technology
59347 readers
4401 users here now
This is a most excellent place for technology news and articles.
Our Rules
- Follow the lemmy.world rules.
- Only tech related content.
- Be excellent to each another!
- Mod approved content bots can post up to 10 articles per day.
- Threads asking for personal tech support may be deleted.
- Politics threads may be removed.
- No memes allowed as posts, OK to post as comments.
- Only approved bots from the list below, to ask if your bot can be added please contact us.
- Check for duplicates before posting, duplicates may be removed
Approved Bots
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
And that "practical use" kills linemen.
I think the correct way to jump is to flip your main so you're disconnected. I'm probably talking out of my ass tho.
I don't own a generator nor have the need. Just basing this on what I've seen in the wild.
The more correct way is to install a switch that does that, so you can be connected to the grid or to the generator, not both. It's basically what you said, but it doesn't trust users to remember to do it correctly
Does such a switch exist?
It does, there's even automatic ones so you can have the generator kick in after a second or two without power and shut off when the grid comes back up
I watched a video on it a week or two ago, I think the general term would be an interlock
Yes, in theory that would work. But they actually make main disconnect switches for this in the event that the main breaker fails. It's a mandatory install in all grid tie electrical generator systems (including solar).
I keep hearing this as the "Reason" but never backed by anything that makes sense. I've never needed to jump my generator to my house, and don't particularly care to even in the event of "disaster" so don't attack me like I'm doing this...
If you successfully suicide jumper your generator to the grid. Wouldn't the collective load of all your neighbors stuff kill the generator? (eg bog it down to the point that it turns off? [if it has no breaker]) Also wouldn't the load of literally your whole neighborhood trip off the breaker in the generator(or in the panel)? Doesn't this leave it as the only "risk" is if you happen to turn on the generator as the lineman themselves are specifically holding a live wire with an active connection to a ground/neutral before the previous stuff can happen? Or only if they happen to isolate you and then you turn on the genny after? Wouldn't you agree that this last thing would be an incredibly rare?
And I can never find an article where a cable was determined to be the cause of an electrocution...
Now because the internet is the internet... I'm not advocating for using suicide cables... There's much easier reasons why this is a terrible idea (exposed live contacts being literally the primary one). But I just never understood the "lineman" argument with all the stuff that would have to go specifically "right" in order to do that kind of harm to a lineman.
Look into it more. It's incredibly common, and the voltage from a small generator in your yard, yes in theory, could leak to neighbors. However electricity follows the shortest path to ground. So if your home is drawing it, you will basically prevent that leakage. If you do fire it up, but use nothing, you may partially leak current to your neighbors (and potentially be liable for damages if your little backyard Honda or generac has a power spike at some point)
And the danger to to the linemen doing repair isn't the voltage necessarily (house current of 120v is not remotely high enough amperage to cause instant death. You can stick a fork in an outlet and try it) it is that you may suddenly electrify lines they are working on while suspended. If you charge the line, maybe you shock them and they have an accident. Or worse, your charged line creates enough of a charge differential that during the repair the much higher voltage electricity they have not isolated yet may bridge the air gap because you've energized the "dead" side prematurely.
In reality, most electricians and linemen are careful of this because of this exact reason. But it did harm a few people before moron's use of these things became common knowledge. Prior to these kinds of cables being commonly marketed for this, a lineman could hop up and reconnect you faster because there was an assumption they had full control of the current pathways. Now that's a toss up. This isn't a recent thing either, but it's becoming more common.
Puerto Rico is a US territory. The US is by definition not a third world country.
https://up.codes/viewer/puerto_rico/ibc-2018/chapter/27/electrical
And doesn't adhere to US electrical code.
Virtually all latin american countries are third world. Puerto Rico is latin american.
Their own people say it's third world. https://www.abc57.com/news/only-on-puerto-rican-businessman-says-home-is-third-world-country
Depends on the definition. Originally used to simply describe the participants of WW2 and the cold war... Since the cold war, it's definition has more aligned with economics and industrialization rather than simply what side a country was on during a war. It's clear by my use of the term that I meant the modern definition, especially since we're talking in 2024... and not in 1989.
https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/third-world-countries
Under the "new" definition many parts of the USA could be considered third world, but I'm not going to argue that.
But fine, I'll modify my statement here...
Puerto Rico is a third world commonwealth.
Nobody... and I mean NOBODY has yet to address the actual electrical engineering part of my question. Instead we've gone off the political bullshit bandwagon. So I'm just going to take it that I'm correct, and that the original premise is bullshit.
Reads like:
Nobody... and I mean NOBODY (i.e. the fifteen people that have seen my posts on Lemmy) has yet to falsify my claim that I'm the second coming of Jesus. So I'm just going to take it that I'm correct, and you can kiss my holy, demi-god ass.
And the fact that you still keep addressing items not on topic simply shows that you're a dickwad. What's your point? I've made a reasoned argument. You've addressed nothing yourself except make really dumb platitudes.
I'm not interested in the question you posed, and I doubt you're sincerely interested in it either as you've spent all of your time worrying about Lemmy replies rather than taking a single step outside of whining to get it answered.
Edit: You're sitting there with basically all of humanity's knowledge at your disposal and you're like, nah, if the randos in this completely unrelated thread don't address my concerns about electrical code it means that my hunches are correct. This is you ---> 🤡
You realize that reasoned argument do take steps to come to right? I've provided sources for things like definitions I've used, and evidence of my understanding of Puerto Rican electrical code. I've literally been the only person in this thread to provide anything.
Why do online "debate me" bros even exist? You're not Socrates debating philosophy in the heart of modern civilization with other scholars here, you're a clown looking for random strangers to answer your questions about technical topics when with a few keystrokes and some sense you could do it yourself.
Do yourself a favor and touch grass.
I'm a "clown" for asking for any shred of evidence that what was stated https://lemmy.world/comment/7213721 is true. Because basic knowledge of electrical systems shows that it really shouldn't be the case except in exceptionally rare cases.
You're the one out here defending random people on the internet as if they're your best friend and you're taking offense that I asked them to explain how what they claimed could be true.
Dude, get a life.
I'm not defending anyone. I don't care much at all about the electrical code, and if I did I'd just look up the information instead of having a stupid hissy fit in the comments of an article about Amazon being declared a distributor.